Thanksgiving is a week away, which means the holiday spending season is already here whether your budget is ready or not. If you haven’t set aside a dime yet, you’re in good company, and you still have about five weeks before Christmas. That’s enough time to pay for a lot of the season in cash, as long as you start this weekend instead of in mid-December.
The stakes are real. LendingTree’s most recent holiday debt survey found that 37% of consumers took on debt during the 2025 holiday season, and the average balance was $1,223, the highest since 2022. Worse, 41% of the people who borrowed last year were still paying off the year before. That’s a cycle where January’s bills never quite go away before the next December arrives.
The country is spending more, and feeling it
The National Retail Federation expects holiday spending in November and December to grow 4.2% over 2025 and top $1 trillion for the first time, landing around $1.013 trillion. At the same time, 56% of shoppers in NRF’s October holiday survey of 8,094 adults said the economy will affect their spending plans.
So people are spending more while worrying more. That tension shows up in how they plan to cover costs. In a follow-up from the same survey, NRF reported that 32% of holiday shoppers plan to cut back on non-holiday spending to make room for gifts, and 22% plan to buy fewer things for themselves. Even among households earning over $150,000, 11% plan to use buy now, pay later services and 10% plan to open additional credit cards.
That last number surprised us. If higher earners are reaching for new credit lines, everyone else should probably have a plan before Black Friday does the planning for them.
Why a credit card balance is so expensive right now
Credit cards aren’t the enemy. They offer fraud protection and rewards, and if you pay the full balance every month they cost you nothing. The trouble starts when the balance rolls over.
According to Bankrate, the average credit card APR was 19.71% as of early November 2026. That’s a bit below the record 20.79% set in August 2024, but it’s still steep. We ran the numbers on the average holiday balance from LendingTree’s survey. If you carried $1,223 at 19.71% and paid $50 a month, it would take you 32 months to clear it, and you’d pay roughly $354 in interest along the way. That’s close to three more Christmases before the first one is paid off.
Paying cash (or with a debit card tied to money you already have) skips all of that. It’s less glamorous than points, but it means January starts at zero.
Week one: pick a number and write it down
Start with a total, not a gift list. Look at your next five paychecks, subtract your fixed bills and normal spending, and see what’s realistically left. That figure is your holiday budget. If it feels small, that’s useful information, and it’s much better to learn it now than when your statement shows up.
Then divide the total among the people and events you’re buying for. Don’t forget the costs that sneak up on people every year: wrapping paper, shipping, the extra grocery run when relatives visit, a host gift, travel gas, and the office gift exchange. We’d suggest holding back about 10% as a cushion for exactly these things.
Week two: give the money its own home
This is the step that makes the plan work. Open a separate savings account, or a second “bucket” if your bank offers sub-accounts, and call it something obvious like “Holidays 2026.” Move your budget into it as each paycheck lands. Many online banks let you set up an automatic transfer on payday, which means you don’t have to remember.
Keeping the money apart from your checking account does two things. You can’t accidentally spend it on takeout, and you can see at a glance how much is left. If the account pays interest, you’ll even earn a little on it for a few weeks. It won’t be much, but it’s more than a credit card will pay you.
Some people take this one step further and load the holiday budget onto a prepaid debit card or a dedicated debit card from their second account. When the card is empty, shopping is over. It’s a blunt tool, and it works.
Week three: shop the sales with a list, not a mood
Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals can be legitimate savings, but only on things you’d already planned to buy. NRF found that 64% of shoppers plan to do most of their shopping around Thanksgiving weekend, so retailers know exactly when you’re paying attention.
Before that weekend, write down specific items and a price ceiling for each. Use price tracking tools or browser extensions to check whether a “doorbuster” is actually lower than its usual price. Turn off one-click checkout. Unsubscribe from a few of the retailer email lists that fill your inbox with “last chance” messages, because there will always be another last chance.
And be careful with buy now, pay later at checkout. Splitting a $200 purchase into four payments feels painless, but several of those plans stacked together can quietly eat a January paycheck. If you do use one, put every payment date on your calendar the same day you buy.
Week four: trim before you borrow
If the numbers still don’t add up, cut before you charge. Suggest a Secret Santa or a dollar limit for the extended family. Most relatives are relieved when someone else brings it up. Swap a few store-bought gifts for homemade food, a framed photo, or an offer of your time. Buy experiences for kids instead of a pile of plastic that’s forgotten by February.
You can also take a page from the 32% of shoppers who plan to trim everyday spending. Pause one or two streaming subscriptions for December, cook at home a few extra nights, and send the difference straight to your holiday account. Small moves add up fast over five weeks.
Week five: check the balance and close it out
The week before Christmas, look at what’s left in your holiday account. If you came in under budget, don’t let it drift back into checking. Leave it where it is and rename the account “Holidays 2027.” Then set up a small automatic transfer, even $25 every two weeks, so next year’s fund starts building in January. At that pace you’d have about $650 by next December without feeling the pinch.
If you went over and had to use a credit card, that’s okay too. Make a plan to pay it off in the first two or three months of the year, before the interest really piles up, and write down what pushed you over so you can budget for it next time.
A quiet January is worth planning for
None of this is complicated. A spending number, a separate account and a written list will carry most families through the season without a balance that lingers into spring. You can still have a generous holiday. You’ll just have paid for it already, so the first credit card statement of 2027 is one you can open without wincing.