Here’s a number that should make you open your banking app before you open any more Black Friday emails. In LendingTree’s survey taken right after last year’s holidays, 37% of consumers said they’d taken on holiday debt, and the average balance was $1,223. That was up from $1,181 the year before and the highest since 2022.
The part that stuck with me came later in the report. Among the people who borrowed for the 2025 holidays, 41% were still paying off debt from the 2024 holidays. For parents of kids under 18 and for six-figure earners, it was half. That’s a lot of people stacking one Christmas on top of another.
Christmas is 38 days away. That’s enough time to keep this year from turning into a two-year payment plan, as long as you start with last year’s leftovers instead of this year’s wish list.
Holiday Spending Is Headed Past $1 Trillion Again
The National Retail Federation forecasts holiday sales of $1.013 trillion for 2026, a 4.2% increase over last year. In 2025, November and December sales grew 3.1% to $972 billion.
Some of that growth is people buying more. A lot of it is the same gifts costing more. Either way, the pressure on your budget is real, and the money mostly goes on plastic. In LendingTree’s survey, 62% of people with holiday debt used credit cards, 35% used buy now, pay later loans, and 32% used store credit cards. Plenty of people used more than one, which is exactly how a balance gets hard to track.
Find Out What You Still Owe From Last Year
Before you set a gift budget, take an honest inventory of what’s left from December 2025. This takes about 20 minutes and it’s the most useful thing you’ll do all season.
Pull up your most recent credit card statement and look at the balance you’re carrying, not the minimum due. Then open any buy now, pay later apps you’ve used (Affirm, Klarna, Afterpay, PayPal Pay in 4, and so on) and check for open plans. Finally, check any store cards. Store cards are where old holiday purchases tend to hide, because the balance is small enough to ignore and the interest rate is usually high.
Add it all up. If the total is zero, great, skip ahead. If it isn’t, that number comes off the top of whatever you planned to spend this year. I know that’s not the fun answer. But putting new gifts on a card that’s still carrying last year’s gifts means you’re paying interest on both.
What a $1,223 Balance Really Costs
Bankrate puts the average credit card APR at 19.71% as of early November. And LendingTree found that 40% of people with holiday debt were paying 20% or more, so the average isn’t the worst case.
Let’s run the average holiday balance, $1,223, through that 19.71% rate. If you clear it in three months, you’ll pay about $421 a month and roughly $40 in interest. Stretch it to six months and the payment drops to about $216, but interest climbs to around $71. Take a full year and you’re paying about $113 a month and about $134 in interest, which means the gifts cost you 11% more than the price tag.
Now the ugly version. If you only pay a typical minimum (1% of the balance plus that month’s interest, with a $25 floor), that same $1,223 takes about 86 months to pay off. That’s more than seven years, and close to $1,000 in interest. You’d be paying off Christmas 2026 in 2033.
Most people aren’t planning on the seven-year version. But LendingTree found 63% of holiday borrowers expected payoff to take three months or longer, and a three-month plan has a way of turning into a twelve-month one once January bills and tax season show up.
Set Your Budget From the Payoff, Not the Wish List
The usual budgeting advice is to decide what you want to spend, then figure out how to pay for it. For holiday shopping, flip it around. Start with how much you can realistically repay, then let that number be your budget.
Here’s a simple version. Look at your cash flow for the rest of November and December and figure out how much you can set aside from each paycheck after rent, utilities, groceries, and any leftover debt from last year. Then add whatever you already have saved for the holidays. That total is your ceiling. If your ceiling is $600, the gift list gets built to $600, and nobody gets a “we’ll figure it out in January” present.
If you’d like to use a credit card for the rewards or the purchase protection, that’s fine. Just treat the card like a debit card. Pay it down every week or so from your checking account, so the balance never gets ahead of the money you actually have.
Put the Money Somewhere You Can See It
A budget that only lives in your head usually loses to a good sale. So give the holiday money its own home.
The easiest approach is a separate savings account, or a named “bucket” inside your current savings account if your bank offers them. Move your holiday ceiling there now. If you need to save part of it from upcoming paychecks, set up an automatic transfer for payday so it moves before you have a chance to spend it on something else. Many online savings accounts still pay meaningful interest, though over five weeks the interest is a rounding error. The real benefit is that you can watch the number go down as you shop.
When the bucket is empty, you’re done shopping. It’s a blunt rule and it works better than willpower.
Be Careful With Buy Now, Pay Later This Year
Buy now, pay later can be a reasonable tool. A four-payment plan with no interest is cheaper than a credit card carrying a balance at 19.71%. The trouble is what happens when you have four or five of them running at once.
Each plan looks small on its own. Stack them up and you can have payments landing every week of January, pulled automatically from your checking account, right when your credit card statement from December arrives too. If one of those pulls hits when your balance is low, you could be looking at a late fee from the lender or an overdraft from your bank.
If you do use BNPL, keep it to one or two plans and put every payment date on your calendar the day you buy. And count those payments against your holiday ceiling just like a credit card purchase. They’re not free money, just money you spend later.
If You’re Already Carrying Last Year’s Balance
If your inventory turned up a balance from last year, give yourself a little grace and then make a plan. Pay more than the minimum on that card every month, starting now. Even an extra $50 a month makes a real dent in the timeline.
If the balance is large and your credit is decent, a 0% balance transfer card might buy you time to pay it down without interest piling up, though most charge an upfront transfer fee and the 0% window eventually ends. Read the terms before you apply. And whatever you do, don’t put new holiday purchases on the card you’re trying to pay off.
The goal for this year doesn’t have to be perfection. It’s just that when January 2027 arrives, the only thing you’re paying for is the stuff you bought in 2026, and ideally not even that.