Dark Mode Light Mode
Certified Refurbished vs New: Why Apple's 15% Refurb Discount Loses to Black Friday This Week
Holiday Return Fees 2026: How to Send Gifts Back Without Losing Part of Your Refund

Holiday Return Fees 2026: How to Send Gifts Back Without Losing Part of Your Refund

Every January, millions of us stand in a customer service line holding a sweater in the wrong size or a gadget nobody wanted. For years that trip cost you nothing but time. That has changed. Retailers now quietly take a cut of plenty of refunds, and the fee usually doesn’t show up until the money la
Shopper carrying shopping bags, illustrating holiday gift returns and return fees Shopper carrying shopping bags, illustrating holiday gift returns and return fees
Photo by Tim Douglas on Pexels

Every January, millions of us stand in a customer service line holding a sweater in the wrong size or a gadget nobody wanted. For years that trip cost you nothing but time. That has changed. Retailers now quietly take a cut of plenty of refunds, and the fee usually doesn’t show up until the money lands back in your account a few dollars short.

The good news is that most of these charges are easy to dodge if you know where they hide. With Black Friday a few days away, now is the time to plan your returns, before you buy anything.

Most Retailers Now Charge for Some Returns

According to the National Retail Federation’s 2025 Retail Returns Landscape report with Happy Returns, retailers expected returns to equal 15.8% of sales, or about $849.9 billion. To claw some of that back, 72% of retailers said they charge for at least some returns, up from 66% the year before.

That is a big shift in a short time. Stores know that free returns encourage people to buy three sizes and keep one, and they’ve decided you should help pay for the shipping and restocking. The fees often look tiny next to the purchase price, which is exactly why they work. Six or eight dollars here and there doesn’t feel like much until you add up a whole family’s worth of gift returns.

What the Big Stores Charge This Season

The extended holiday windows are generous this year. A roundup of 2026 holiday return policies published this week shows Walmart, Kohl’s, Macy’s, JCPenney, and Amazon all accepting most holiday purchases through January 31, 2027. Best Buy gives most shoppers until January 15, 2027. The fees are where the fine print gets interesting.

Macy’s charges $9.99 for return shipping unless you’re a Star Rewards member, and it comes straight out of your refund. JCPenney takes $8 per online order you send back through UPS, though in-store returns are free. Kohl’s doesn’t provide a prepaid label for mail returns, so you pay the postage yourself, and it charges a 15% restocking fee on freight items unless they’re defective.

Electronics carry the steepest penalties. Best Buy charges $45 to return activatable devices like phones and 15% on certain items such as cameras, drones, and projectors, depending on whether the box was opened and which state you live in. Walmart’s Marketplace major appliances can face restocking fees of up to 20%. Amazon can keep anywhere from 20% to 100% of an item’s price for a late return, and up to 50% if the item comes back damaged or missing parts.

Smaller apparel brands have joined in too. Last season, J. Crew charged $7.50 for a prepaid mail label, Zara charged $4.95 per return request, Urban Outfitters took $5 on most mailed returns, and Marshalls charged $11.99 per mailed return, according to CBS News and Market Realist. Check each store’s current policy before you order, since these numbers can change mid-season.

The Simplest Fix: Walk It Back to the Store

Almost every mail-return fee disappears when you return the item in person. JCPenney, Macy’s, and Marshalls all charge for shipping but take items back at the counter for free. If you have a store within a reasonable drive, that trip is worth roughly $8 to $12 per package.

Amazon works a little differently. Last season it waived its return fee for shoppers who used a label-free, box-free drop-off at locations like Kohl’s, Whole Foods, and Staples. When you start a return in the app, look at every drop-off option before choosing one. The free choice is usually there, just not always listed first.

One more trick: bundle your returns. If you’re already heading to the mall for one gift, bring every other return you owe to that area. Gas and time count as costs too, and one well-planned errand beats four separate trips.

Join the Loyalty Program Before You Buy

Several of these fees only apply to non-members. Macy’s waives its $9.99 shipping charge for Star Rewards members, and Best Buy’s paid Plus and Total members get until January 31, 2027 to return purchases made between October 30 and December 3.

Free loyalty programs are worth signing up for before your holiday order, not after. It takes two minutes and an email address. Paid memberships are a different call. Don’t pay for a membership just to save a single $10 return fee, but if you were already planning a big electronics purchase, the longer window has real value.

Watch the Calendar, Especially for Electronics

The extended windows have exceptions that catch people off guard. At Best Buy, holiday decorations get only 15 days and most activatable devices just 14. At Walmart, major appliances must come back within two days, and wireless phones, protection plans, and most Marketplace items are excluded from the extended window. Amazon gives Apple products bought during the holidays only until January 15, 2027.

A missed deadline is the most expensive return fee of all, because it can mean no refund. Put the return date in your phone’s calendar the day you buy anything you’re unsure about. If you’re gifting something pricey, tuck the gift receipt in with the present so the recipient isn’t stuck guessing.

Keep the Packaging Until You’re Sure

Restocking fees often hinge on whether the item is unopened. Best Buy’s 15% charge, for example, depends partly on whether the box was opened. For anything expensive, open the shipping box but leave the product packaging sealed until you know it’s a keeper. Save the original boxes, accessories, and manuals until the return window closes. An item that comes back missing a cable can trigger Amazon’s partial refund of up to 50%.

Where Your Refund Goes Matters Too

Refunds return to the original payment method, so a gift returned in January might take a week or more to post. If you paid with a debit card, that money is tied up in the meantime. Using a credit card you pay in full each month keeps your checking balance intact while you wait, and it gives you dispute rights if a store refuses a legitimate return.

When the refund does arrive, move it somewhere useful instead of letting it disappear into everyday spending. Sending January refunds into a high-yield savings account is an easy way to rebuild what December drained. A $60 sweater refund won’t change your life, but five or six of them add up to a decent start on next year’s gift fund.

Before You Shop This Black Friday

Before you click buy on anything this Black Friday, read the store’s holiday return policy, note the deadline, and check whether mail returns cost money. Sign up for any free loyalty program that waives fees. Keep packaging sealed on big-ticket items, and plan to return things in person whenever you can. Retailers are counting on most people not doing any of this, which is why the fees exist in the first place.

Financial Freedom in Your Inbox

By pressing the Subscribe button, you confirm that you have read and are agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
Previous Post
Silver laptop on a desk, illustrating the certified refurbished vs new buying decision

Certified Refurbished vs New: Why Apple's 15% Refurb Discount Loses to Black Friday This Week